Understanding Culturally Diverse Privacy - Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples' perspectives - Office of the Victorian Information Commissioner (2023)

From Monday 12 September 2020, OVIC's website will no longer be supported in Internet Explorer (IE).
We recommend installing Microsoft Edge, Google Chrome, Safari, Firefox, or Opera to visit the site.

Understanding Culturally Diverse Privacy - Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples' perspectives - Office of the Victorian Information Commissioner (1)

The Office of the Victorian Information Commissioner acknowledges the Aboriginal Traditional Owners of Country throughout Victoria and pays respect to their cultures and Elders past, present and emerging.

The artwork by Jordan Lovegrove, a Ngarrindjeri man of Dreamtime Creative, shows OVICprotecting information rights for different peopleandcommunities. The large central meeting place represents OVICwhile the smaller meeting places around the outside show thedifferent communities.The dotted pathways and the dots in the centre represent OVIC protecting communities information.

Introduction

Privacy is a complex concept, encompassing many interrelated ideas and influenced by factors such as age, background and culture. It is also not a fixed concept; different people and different groups will experience, understand, and value privacy in varied ways, which can change over time.

One dimension of privacy is the notion of control over one’s personal information. Commonly referred to as information privacy, this relates to an individual’s ability to determine when, how, and for what purpose their personal information is used. Many privacy laws, including the Privacy and Data Protection Act 2014 (Vic) (PDP Act), regulate information privacy and the protection of personal information.

In Victoria, privacy is also a human right enshrined in the Charter of Human Rights and Responsibilities Act 2006 (the Charter), which requires Victorian public authorities to consider how privacy is protected when creating legislation, implementing policies, or delivering services. The right to privacy under the Charter is broader than the concept of information privacy, referring to an individual’s right not to have their privacy, family life, home or correspondence (such as mail or email) interfered with.

The right to privacy (both in terms of information privacy and privacy more broadly) as protected under the PDP Act and the Charter respectively, focuses on the rights of individuals. But privacy can also be conceived as a group right, rather than an individual right alone. For example, some groups or cultures – such as Indigenous groups – may focus on collective rights in relation to information, and a privacy interest may affect not only the individual to whom the information relates, but also the wider group to which the individual may belong.

Further, while the PDP Act and other privacy laws define what constitutes personal information, different groups and individuals may have varying views around what they consider to be personal (and sensitive) information, which may not necessarily align with the definitions under privacy legislation.

Purpose of this paper

As the primary regulator for information privacy in Victoria with administration over the PDP Act, the Office of the Victorian Information Commissioner (OVIC) seeks to better understand how different cultures perceive information privacy, in particular Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities in Victoria. Gaining an awareness and understanding of different cultural attitudes towards information privacy may help to address some of the barriers and challenges to the collection, use and disclosure of personal information of individuals from different backgrounds.

This paper draws on the findings of research conducted by the Cultural and Indigenous Research Centre Australia (CIRCA) for OVIC between April and June 2020. It will outline potential considerations for the Victorian public sector (VPS) when collecting, using and disclosing Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples’ personal information, with reference to the PDP Act. OVIC hopes that this paper will give an insight into Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander perspectives towards the handling of personal information and provide a starting point for discussion into cultural privacy.

Context

In 2002, the former Office of the Victorian Privacy Commissioner published a report, Privacy in diverse Victoria (OVPC report), which looked at attitudes towards information privacy amongst culturally and linguistically diverse communities and Indigenous groups in Victoria. The report noted several issues raised by Indigenous individuals, including:

  • concerns around the overcollection and sharing of personal information;
  • concerns around personal information being misused against the individual, and incorrect information being held by the collecting organisation;
  • a desire for control when personal information is shared – for example, knowing why the information is being collected, how it will be used, and having the ability to provide consent and check the accuracy of the information being shared; and
  • accepting the ‘inevitable’ sharing of personal information, if it benefits the community or individual; for example, if the sharing helps to protect children.

Since the release of this report, little to no further research has been conducted in Victoria into Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples’ attitudes towards information privacy.

(Video) NRCoP: What is culturally responsive regulation?

Elsewhere, the Australian Law Reform Commission’s (ALRC) 2008 report For Your Information: Australian Privacy Law and Practice explored the privacy of Indigenous groups, and the idea of privacy protocols to protect those groups’ privacy rights.

The use of a privacy protocol to assist organisations in addressing the particular privacy needs of Indigenous groups (and other ethnic or cultural groups) is not new. In 1998 the federal Office of the Privacy Commissioner developed a privacy protocol to assist Commonwealth agencies handling the personal information of Indigenous people in the Northern Territory. The protocol aimed to provide an interpretation of some aspects of the Information Privacy Principles under the federal Privacy Act 1988 in a way that was culturally appropriate for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people in the Northern Territory. For example, it listed examples of culturally sensitive information, disclosure of personal information to third parties, and issues relating to the collection of personal information.

CIRCA research and findings

OVIC’s aim in commissioning the CIRCA research was to gain a better understanding of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples’ attitudes towards information privacy – specifically, their views on the cultural appropriateness of certain practices relating to the collection, use and disclosure of personal information. The research was limited to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples living in Victoria (noting the diversity of communities, cultures and languages within the state).

Scope and methodology

CIRCA’s research focused on the collection, uses, and disclosures of personal information and, through the use of hypothetical scenarios, whether certain practices were considered to be culturally inappropriate or insensitive. The research also looked at ideas for building trust in organisations’ collection and handling of the personal information of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander individuals.

As part of the research, CIRCA conducted focus group interviews with a diverse mix of 12 Aboriginal participants living in Victoria. Given the small sample size, the findings are not representative of the views of all Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander individuals. Nonetheless, the research identifies important themes and privacy considerations for organisations collecting and handling the personal information of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples – and, indeed, the broader community.

Additionally, as the PDP Act protects the information privacy rights of individuals, it should be noted that CIRCA’s research focuses only on individual rights in relation to privacy and personal information. However, as noted above, some cultures – including Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander cultures – may consider certain types of information as belonging to the group rather than to individuals, and as such may place a greater emphasis on collective, versus individual rights.

Key findings – collection of personal information

CIRCA’s research identified several issues raised by Aboriginal participants in relation to the collection of personal information. In particular, participants had concerns with being asked to provide personal information of individuals other than themselves to government organisations.

Participants reported that they would be uncomfortable providing personal information about other individuals (for example, family members) to organisations requesting this data, citing reasons such as consent not having been provided by that other individual, and that individual not being able to be informed about how their information will be used.

Notably, some participants also raised cultural concerns around the provision of information about other individuals:

“…it’s not culturally appropriate to share personal information of our Elders or peers…with people outside our immediate or even part extended family… So even if it was a community organisation you trusted or a completely different organisation, it’s still culturally inappropriate to share more than basic information to anyone outside the family.”

The research also asked participants about methods of data collection. While there was no particular method considered to be more culturally appropriate or inappropriate than others, participants noted their preferred method of collection depends on the context and circumstances. In the hypothetical scenario of applying for a government service, some participants preferred the convenience of online collection, while others noted technological literacy, the ability to build a relationship with the organisation, and being able to interact with a person with an awareness of Aboriginal people and their culture as reasons for preferring an in-person collection of their personal information.

Key findings – use and disclosure of personal information

In terms of use and disclosure of personal information, most participants expressed being unhappy in the hypothetical scenario of an organisation using personal information held about them for a secondary use other than the original purpose of collection, even where the secondary use or disclosure was legitimate or legally permitted:

“I feel the data you provide should only be used for the purpose you originally provided it for, not so that [they] can re-use the data.”

The need for consent was raised, particularly in the context of disclosure of personal information to other organisations. Being informed about the purpose for disclosure was also important to participants. One participant noted:

“…some [information] you felt you could share with [one] agency you would not share [with the other] due to cultural reasons”

Some participants raised the issue of trust in an organisation, and how this could be eroded where disclosure of their personal information to a third party occurred without their consent or knowledge.

Key findings – trust in organisations

CIRCA’s research identified several key issues in relation to trust in organisations’ collection and handling of personal information. Aboriginal participants who participated in the research cited a number of different reasons for distrust in organisations, such as:

  • colonisation and historical injustices;
  • a lack of transparency;
  • power imbalances (between the organisation collecting the data and the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples from whom the data is collected); and
  • organisations not adequately accommodating for the needs of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples.

“A high percentage of government [organisations] and community services don’t actually have any culturally appropriate processes in place to share sensitive information about, for, and on behalf of Aboriginal people”

(Video) Human Rights in Action: Cultural Rights of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples

The research sought participants’ views on how organisations could build trust with Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples. Several ways to enhance trust were identified, which are outlined below.

Privacy considerations

This section considers privacy considerations in relation to the Information Privacy Principles (IPPs) under the PDP Act, in light of the findings summarised above. The IPPs provide a minimum standard for the collection, storage, handling and disposal of personal information held by VPS organisations.

Collection of personal information

IPP 1 (Collection) outlines a number of requirements for organisations when collecting personal information. For example:

  • it must be necessary for one or more of an organisation’s functions or activities (IPP 1.1);
  • the collection must be lawful, fair, and not unreasonably intrusive (IPP 1.2);
  • organisations must take reasonable steps to provide individuals with certain details about the collection (IPP 1.3); and
  • where reasonable and practicable, organisations must collect personal information directly from the individual (IPP 1.4).

Direct vs indirect collection

IPP 1.4 requires organisations, where reasonable and practicable, to collect personal information about an individual only from that individual. Collecting personal information directly ensures that individuals are aware of the collection, and provides them with control over what is collected, by whom and for what purpose. The importance of individuals being aware of the collection of their personal information was raised in CIRCA’s research, along with their being informed of the purposes for which the information will be used or disclosed.

Organisations have an obligation under IPP 1.5 to take reasonable steps to provide a notice of collection where personal information is collected indirectly, but in cases of indirect collection individuals are not given the opportunity to refuse collection, or provide consent for certain uses or disclosures, which, as will be explored further in this paper, is an important issue identified by many participants.

Collecting personal information directly from individuals can help to ensure that the information is accurate, complete and up to date. On the other hand, indirect collection raises the risk that personal information collected from a source other than the relevant individual is incomplete or out of date. For example, collecting personal information indirectly from publicly available sources such as social media poses the risk that the information is inaccurate or no longer up to date. Individuals may also not be aware that personal information is being collected from their social media, and therefore do not have the opportunity to refuse the collection or provide accurate details.

Indirect collection could also potentially lead to organisations inadvertently collecting information that may not be considered culturally appropriate to share with that organisation.

Sensitive information

The PDP Act lists nine categories of sensitive information, including information relating to an individual’s racial and ethnic origin. IPP 10 (Sensitive Information) places greater limitations around the collection of sensitive information, which acknowledges that this type of information carries inherent risks to individuals’ privacy and other rights. For example, one risk commonly associated with the collection and handling of sensitive information is discrimination on the basis of racial or ethnic origin, political opinions, or sexual practices.

Many organisations commonly collect information about racial or ethnic origin (for example, identification or status as an Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander person) for purposes such as providing community-specific services or recruitment for a designated role. However, Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander individuals may be reluctant to provide this type of sensitive information for reasons such as historical and contemporary experiences of racism and discrimination, fear of negative consequences, uncertainty and mistrust about why the information is being collected and how it will be used, and cultural stereotyping.

The Australian Bureau of Statistics’ (ABS) 2014 Review of the Indigenous Status Standard (the basis for the ABS and many other organisations’ collection of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander statistics) found that a lack of understanding around why information about Indigenous status is collected and what the data is used for can lead to an unwillingness to provide this information. Further, the ABS noted that ‘understanding why the data is collected strongly correlates with higher levels of compliance and improved data quality’.

Providing individuals with adequate details about why Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander identification is being collected and what it will be used for is essential to individuals’ ability to give informed, meaningful consent, which is commonly relied upon as the basis for collecting sensitive information under IPP 10.

Use and disclosure of personal information

Under the PDP Act, organisations must not use or disclose personal information for a purpose other than the original purpose of collection, unless an exception under IPP 2 applies. These exceptions include:

  • where the secondary use or disclosure is related to the primary purpose of collection and is reasonably expected by the individual (IPP 2.1(a));
  • with the consent of the individual (IPP 2.1(b)); or
  • where the use or disclosure is required or authorised by or under another law (IPP 2.1(f)).

Consent

While consent is only one of the legal bases under which organisations can use or disclose personal information for a secondary purpose under the PDP Act, many Aboriginal participants who took part in CIRCA’s research placed great value on consent and having the ability to control the use and disclosure of their personal information, even in circumstances where its secondary use or disclosure would have been permitted without consent.

“Without consent or prior knowledge, I always have a problem with data sharing. The benefit of any data sharing is outweighed by people’s right to privacy and control over their own data.”

When relying on individuals’ consent to use or disclose their personal information, consent must be meaningful. This can be challenging, as discussed further below.

(Video) Solomon Lecture 2022

Reasonably expected

Another common basis for secondary use or disclosure of personal information is where it is related to the primary purpose of collection, and is reasonably expected by the individual. Whether a use or disclosure is ‘reasonably expected’ depends on what an ordinary person would consider reasonable in the particular circumstances (rather than the expectation of the actual individual concerned). What an ordinary person would consider reasonable can be influenced by a range of factors, including the nature of the organisation, the sensitivity of the information, and the individual’s expressed expectations.

Community expectations can also play an important role in determining what is considered reasonable in the particular circumstances. Victoria has diverse Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities, whose expectations around how personal information should be used and disclosed, and views around what uses or disclosures are culturally acceptable or inappropriate, may differ across communities. This is reflected in one Aboriginal participant’s comment which, while related to collection, is nonetheless relevant in the context of use and disclosure:

“Data collection could be made more culturally appropriate by not expecting all Indigenous peoples to fit in one box.”

Another factor that can influence reasonable expectations is the notice provided to the individual upon collection of their personal information. Under IPP 1.3, organisations are required to take reasonable steps to make individuals aware of certain information (often referred to as a collection notice), including the purposes for which their personal information is collected, and organisations or individuals to whom that information is usually disclosed. A good collection notice can set up an individual’s expectations about how their personal information will be used and disclosed, as required under IPP 2.1(a).

Data quality

IPP 3 (Data Quality) requires VPS organisations to take reasonable steps to ensure the personal information they collect, use or disclose is accurate, complete, and up to date. Ensuring the data quality of personal information is important, as personal information is often used to make decisions that affect communities and individuals’ lives. For example, an incorrect age can affect an individual’s concession entitlements, or inaccurate personal information about an individual involved in an investigation can cause serious harm.

Collecting personal information directly from an individual (compared to indirect collection) is one way to ensure the quality of the information. Several studies and best practice guidelines (largely within the context of health service provision) have noted self-identification (also self-reporting) as the most accurate means of ascertaining an individual’s Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander status – as opposed to the data collecting organisation making an assumption based on factors such as appearance or language, and recording this assumption on the individual’s behalf.

Taking reasonable steps to check that such information is up to date before it is used or disclosed is also important, particularly as individuals may choose to identify or not identify as Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander at different stages of their life. Providing individuals with the opportunity to confirm or amend this information (as well as other categories of their personal information) is therefore essential for ensuring data quality under IPP 3.

Transparency

Transparency about organisations’ use and disclosure of personal information was a major theme identified in CIRCA’s research, with Aboriginal participants frequently highlighting the importance of being aware of the purposes for which their personal information would be used, particularly in the context of secondary use or disclosure to third parties.

“…when we give [information] to government they tell us how it will be used, but I feel we never really know what else it is being used for. Government agencies share information all the time and I feel this is not explained to people enough.”

Being transparent about secondary uses or disclosures of personal information can help promote trust and accountability. It can also help foster a positive relationship between the organisation and individual or community, which can be valuable for public acceptance of new programs or projects involving the use of personal and sensitive information. Additionally, as noted above, being transparent about how personal or sensitive information will be used or disclosed can help ensure the quality of data being collected, as individuals are more likely to share accurate information about themselves if they are comfortable with how it will be used and shared.

This principle of transparency underpins IPP 5 (Openness), which requires organisations to set out their policies on the management of personal information in a publicly available document, often referred to as a privacy policy.

Consent

Consent is a fundamental concept underpinning many privacy laws, including the PDP Act. In the context of information privacy, consent refers to the ability of individuals to make choices (in certain circumstances) about when and how their personal information is collected and used. While consent is only one basis among many that organisations can rely on to use or disclose personal information for a secondary purpose, CIRCA’s research demonstrated that for the Aboriginal participants, being able to control how their information is used and shared, through the provision of consent, is essential.

“I wouldn’t appreciate my data being shared without my permission, or someone contacting me for their own purpose, not for my actual benefit.”

However, consent should be meaningful. Meaningful consent has five elements: it must be informed, voluntary, current, specific, and given by an individual with capacity to agree with what is being asked of them. For example, for consent to be voluntary, individuals must be able to exercise genuine control. Seeking consent for a secondary use or disclosure that is permitted under a law, and which will occur irrespective of whether consent is given or not, may seem disingenuous, and the consent will likely be invalid. Similarly, consent will likely not be voluntary where the provision of consent is conditional to accessing a service, or an organisation seeks consent for the collection of sensitive information it is legally permitted to collect without consent.

Another element that is particularly relevant in light of CIRCA’s research is that consent must be informed. This involves individuals knowing all the relevant facts, including who their information will be shared with and what it will be used for. Importantly, informed consent depends on the individual understanding the information presented to them, taking into account any particular vulnerabilities. For example, providing information about how personal information will be used does not necessarily mean the individual will understand that information. Individuals’ literacy levels may vary, which can impact on their understanding of how their personal information will be used and disclosed. Similarly, framing information in a way that individuals are not familiar with – such as using highly technical or legal language – may also impact on individuals’ ability to provide informed consent. This is reflected in one Aboriginal participant’s comment, in relation to challenges in communicating with organisations about data collection and use practices:

“Jargon is a major factor. It’s not clearly written for many to understand, and many people just sign up for things without knowing the consequences.”

This ties into another element of consent: capacity. An individual may not be capable of providing consent due to factors such as cultural and linguistic differences, and level of literacy, including digital literacy.

(Video) Victorian Law Week 2022: Cultural Diversity in the Law

Building trust

Trust is essential for government to be able to build and maintain legitimacy and acceptance from the public to collect and use citizens’ personal information, deliver good services, and develop a positive relationship with its citizens. Building trust in the collection, use and disclosure of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples’ personal information is particularly important, given the historical and ongoing injustices and misuses of personal information experienced by individuals in those communities.

While compliance with privacy laws is crucial, CIRCA’s research demonstrates that this is only one element of a broader strategy needed to foster trust in an organisation’s collection and handling of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples’ personal information. Aboriginal participants in CIRCA’s research identified several other essential elements to help build trust.

Consultation and community control

Participants noted the importance of genuine and respectful consultation with Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities on matters relating to their information privacy, and allowing input into how their personal information is used. Noting the diversity and complexity of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities, consultation can be valuable for ensuring the use of personal information aligns with community expectations. It also plays an important role in fostering public acceptance and uptake of programs involving personal information and can help build trust in organisations’ use of personal information.

Another suggestion provided by participants was community control, which goes beyond consultation to empower and enable Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities to handle and make decisions about their own personal information. Community control allows Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities to be involved in their own affairs in accordance with protocols or procedures determined by the community, and is closely tied to the notion of Aboriginal self-determination (broadly, the right for Aboriginal peoples to make decisions on matters that affect their lives and communities).

This need for community control of data is recognised in the Victorian Government’s Victorian Aboriginal Affairs Framework 2018-2023, which is underpinned by the principle of Aboriginal self-determination: “…increasing Aboriginal ownership and control of data is a key enabler of self-determination”. As one Aboriginal participant reflected:

“While data may be used to develop policies to assist mob, I have real issues with who is developing those policies and who has ownership of the data that is collected… Now more than ever Government should be helping to fund Aboriginal [organisations] to do the work and store the data so there is oversight by mob of how it is used.”

Effective communication

Communicating effectively with individuals about information privacy matters can be a challenge for many organisations. For example, privacy policies – which are a key source of information about how an organisation uses and discloses personal information – are often lengthy, complex and difficult to understand, and few individuals meaningfully engage with them. This issue of effective communication is crucial as it has implications for consent – if individuals cannot fully understand how their personal information will be used, they are unlikely to be able to provide informed, meaningful consent.

The importance of effective communication was identified by many Aboriginal participants in CIRCA’s research, along with the need to use different approaches to cater to different levels of education and literacy, and tailoring the communication for the specific audience; for example:

  • minimising jargon;
  • using infographics to assist with understanding; and
  • framing issues in culturally appropriate language that Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people can better relate to.

The need for more support and education for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander individuals regarding privacy matters was also identified, with one participant noting:

“I think not enough education is provided to community using services and their rights of information privacy and data collection when using such services… Educate our people; don’t hide it in the signing of documents.”

These issues were similarly raised in the ABS’ research exploring perspectives on Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander identification, which raised literacy and language as one factor in individuals’ tendency to identify as Indigenous; in particular, the ABS noted the need to provide support to those who require assistance with reading forms or understanding questions in English.In its report Strangers in their own land: Use of Aboriginal Interpreters by NT public authorities, the Ombudsman NT cautioned against overestimating individuals’ English proficiency and noted that ultimately, organisations have a responsibility to ensure effective communication. The report states that ‘ensuring effective communication may be complicated by a range of cultural and social factors… but these complications are for the agency to recognise and manage’. The use of Aboriginal interpreters (the topic of the NT Ombudsman’s report) in appropriate circumstances may be one strategy to enable organisations to better communicate with individuals about privacy matters.

Seeking consent

Control over personal information and how it is used and disclosed, through the provision of consent, is a consistent theme raised by participants throughout CIRCA’s research. Participants noted the need for such consent to be informed, and for individuals providing it to fully understand what they were consenting to. As noted above, while it is not feasible in all circumstances to seek consent, and obtaining meaningful consent can be challenging, doing so where practicable can foster trust between organisations and Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples, with consent raised by participants as one strategy for building trust.

Organisational reform and a human centred approach

“To be more culturally sensitive, organisations need to have an understanding of issues that Indigenous people face regularly, and be respectful and mindful of how systems affect us.”

The need for reform to promote and ensure culturally safe and inclusive services was noted by participants as another way for organisations to foster trust. Collecting data from Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people in a respectful and sensitive way could also enhance individuals’ willingness to provide personal information voluntarily, as well as improve data quality.

The Victorian Family Violence Data Collection Framework describes cultural safety as an environment ‘where services are provided in a manner that is respectful of a person’s culture and beliefs, and that is free from discrimination’. Ensuring a culturally safe environment requires organisations to analyse their organisational culture and ensure that it does not have a negative impact on the cultural rights of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities. This may involve examining policies and processes to ensure they are inclusive of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people, providing cultural awareness training to staff, and accommodating the needs of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities.

Some examples given by participants included:

  • tailoring services specific to “men’s and women’s” business;
  • adopting a more personalised approach towards data collection that builds trust, rather than treating individuals as simply a ‘number’ – for example, face to face interaction with communities;
  • providing the option to deal with Aboriginal liaison officers; and
  • recognising the diversity of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities, rather than a one size fits all approach.

The importance of cultural awareness on the part of organisations collecting data was also recognised in previous research conducted by the ABS, as a key factor in improving Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander identification. The attitude of data collection staff was also highlighted; that is, ‘the need for staff to understand, and be able to explain, the reason for collecting the data’, as well as ‘the need for a positive interaction around identification’.

Conclusion

A better understanding of different cultural perspectives around the collection, use and disclosure of personal information is essential for promoting a culturally sensitive and appropriate approach towards the handling of such information, in addition to complying with Victorian privacy laws. Handling personal information in a culturally safe manner has benefits for both individuals and organisations alike – such as enhancing trust, improving data quality, and improved understanding about how personal information will be used.

(Video) 2019 Solomon Lecture

OVIC encourages VPS organisations to consider the issues discussed in this paper and think about ways to make their processes for the collection and handling of personal information more culturally sensitive.

Finally, OVIC would like to thank CIRCA for their research, and the participants who took part for their time.

FAQs

What are three 3 resources for gathering information about local Aboriginal and or Torres Strait Islander people? ›

You could also try the following resources: The Indigenous Portal, a window to resources, contacts, information, and government programs and services for Aboriginal people and Torres Strait Islanders. Aboriginal Studies WWW Virtual Library is an Internet guide to online aboriginal studies websites.

What is cultural competence regarding Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander culture? ›

This includes gaining knowledge and understanding of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander culture, customs and histories; taking action in a culturally safe and appropriate way; and demonstrating authentic respect for Indigenous culture in all interactions. Cultural competency is a practical act of reconciliation.

What are the five interconnected elements of aboriginal culture? ›

Land, family, law, ceremony and language are five key interconnected elements of Indigenous culture. For example, families are connected to the land through the kinship system, and this connection to land comes with specific roles and responsibilities which are enshrined in the law and observed through ceremony.

What are four important aspects of Aboriginal culture? ›

Family, land, law, and language are four critical aspects of Aboriginal culture, and Aboriginal families are linked to land via kinship systems.

What are four issues that aboriginals face when engaging with community services? ›

Aboriginal communities are also suffering from a mix of issues, often a consequence of the trauma people have experienced:
  • Lack of services. ...
  • Lack of medical care. ...
  • Little education. ...
  • High unemployment. ...
  • Staff exhaustion. ...
  • Decaying infrastructure. ...
  • Broken families. ...
  • High crime rates.
27 Aug 2021

Why is it important to keep Aboriginal information confidential? ›

Building trust in the collection, use and disclosure of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples' personal information is particularly important, given the historical and ongoing injustices and misuses of personal information experienced by individuals in those communities.

What are the 4 C's of cultural competence? ›

Cultural competence is comprised of four components: (a) Awareness of one's own cultural worldview, (b) Attitude towards cultural differences, (c) Knowledge of different cultural practices and worldviews, and; (d) Cross cultural Skills.

What are 4 key areas one must recognize in order to ensure cultural competence? ›

Cultural competence has four major components: awareness, attitude, knowledge, and skills.

What are the 5 components of cultural competence? ›

Cultural competemility is defined as the synergistic process between cultural humility and cultural competence in which cultural humility permeates each of the five components of cultural competence: cultural awareness, cultural knowledge, cultural skill, cultural desire, and cultural encounters.

What are Aboriginal cultural values? ›

Aboriginal people have a rich culture involving a custom, lore and value system based on the sustainability of their spiritual connection, belonging, obligation and responsibility to care for their land, their people and their environment.

Why is it important to have an awareness of the diversity of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander cultures think of the different clans across Australia? ›

Cultural awareness shows respect for the culture with whom one is working, which can aid people working with these communities to build better relationships and be more effective in their work.

Why is the number 4 important to Indigenous Peoples? ›

The Number 4

This cultural concept is based on the Aboriginal belief that natural occurrences happen in fours and four is a sacred number.

What cultural issues affect Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders? ›

Discrimination, racism and lack of cultural understanding mean that Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people still experience inequality and social injustice. People's cultural beliefs, values and world-views influence thinking, behaviours and interactions with others.

How do you effectively communicate with Aboriginal people? ›

Use formal addresses when interacting with older people and Elders—or ask them how they wish to be acknowledged. Always wait your turn to speak. It is important to be a good listener and not to talk over anyone. Avoid direct criticisms of specific individuals.

What are three potential cultural safety issues for Aboriginal? ›

This includes addressing unconscious bias, racism and discrimination, and supporting Aboriginal self-determination. Individuals, organisations and systems ensuring their cultural values do not negatively impact on Aboriginal peoples, including addressing the potential for unconscious bias, racism and discrimination.

Why is it difficult for aboriginals to access community services? ›

Fear of racism, disrespect, judgement and negative government interventions were reported as barriers to Aboriginal people accessing some mainstream healthcare services.

Why is it important to maintain privacy confidentiality and disclosure? ›

There is a clear relationship between confidentiality and privacy. A breach of confidentiality can result in disclosure of information which might intrude on the privacy of a person or an organisation.

Why is it important to keep people's information confidential? ›

Confidentiality is important because:

It prevents misuse of confidential information (illegal or immoral use). It protects reputation. Employment may depend on it (e.g. non-disclosure agreement). It ensures compliance with the law.

Why is protecting culture so important to Indigenous Peoples? ›

It is the basis of traditions, customs, protocols, values, spirituality, ceremonies, language, ways of knowing and being, and connections to the land and the life-sustaining resources of the land. Culture permeates all aspects of life and is essential to the overall well-being of Indigenous communities and individuals.

What are the four 4 major factors that affect cross cultural communication? ›

Six key barriers for cross-cultural communications
  • 1- Ethnocentrism. We all have a natural tendency to look at other cultures through our own lenses. ...
  • 2- Stereotyping. ...
  • 3- Psychological barriers. ...
  • 4- Language barriers. ...
  • 5- Geographical distance. ...
  • 6- Conflicting values.
9 Jul 2018

What are the 3 levels of cultural competence? ›

Displaying the cultural competence behaviors of active listening, demonstrating empathy, and effective engagement is important when moving beyond tolerance. These three components will help us to create a welcoming environment and establish the appreciation of similarities and differences among cultures.

What is the 4c concept? ›

The 4Cs are customer, cost, convenience and communication. By learning to use the 4Cs model, you'll have the chance to think about your product from a new perspective (the customer's) and that could be very good for business. Here's how to use the 4Cs to best position your product in a competitive market.

How do you promote cultural awareness in the workplace? ›

SEVEN PRACTICES YOU CAN IMPLEMENT TO INCREASE CULTURAL AWARENESS IN THE WORKPLACE
  1. Get training for global citizenship. ...
  2. Bridge the culture gap with good communication skills. ...
  3. Practice good manners. ...
  4. Celebrate traditional holidays, festivals, and food. ...
  5. Observe and listen to foreign customers and colleagues.
22 Sept 2017

What are the 3 three principles that are required of you to be culturally competent within your work space and or personal environment? ›

These attributes will guide you in developing cultural competence: Self-knowledge and awareness about one's own culture. Awareness of one's own cultural worldview. Experience and knowledge of different cultural practices.

What are the 5 stages of cultural awareness? ›

Have the capacity to (1) value diversity, (2) conduct self-assessment, (3) manage the dynamics of difference, (4) acquire and institutionalize cultural knowledge, and (5) adapt to diversity and the cultural contexts of communities they serve.

What are the 4 key elements of culture? ›

The major elements of culture are symbols, language, norms, values, and artifacts. Language makes effective social interaction possible and influences how people conceive of concepts and objects.

What are 3 examples of strategies to help improve culturally competent care? ›

WHAT IS CULTURAL COMPETENCE IN HEALTH CARE?
  • Provide interpreter services.
  • Recruit and retain minority staff.
  • Provide training to increase cultural awareness, knowledge, and skills.
  • Coordinate with traditional healers.
  • Use community health workers.
  • Incorporate culture-specific attitudes and values into health promotion tools.

What are the four stages of cultural awareness? ›

This awareness tends to progress through a series of levels, described below.
  • I. Unconscious incompetence. ...
  • II. Conscious incompetence. ...
  • III. Conscious competence. ...
  • IV. Unconscious competence. ...
  • ... To explore the Four Levels of Cultural Awareness see if you can recognize them...

What are the 5 rights of Indigenous people? ›

The rights of ownership and possession of ICCs/IPs to their ancestral domains shall include: (a) the right of ownership; (b) the right to develop, control and use lands and natural resources; (c) the right to stay in the territories and not to be removed therefrom; (d) the right of resettlement in suitable sites in ...

What are the 3 important rights of the indigenous peoples? ›

Indigenous peoples have the right to manifest, practise, develop and teach their spiritual and religious traditions, customs and ceremonies; the right to maintain, protect, and have access in privacy to their religious and cultural sites; the right to the use and control of ceremonial objects; and the right to the ...

What are the 3 main groups of indigenous peoples? ›

Aboriginal group refers to whether the person is First Nations (North American Indian), Métis or Inuk (Inuit).

What is the most important thing in Aboriginal culture? ›

The importance of “being on country

Aboriginal culture is holistic, defined by its connection to family, community and country. In Australia, the idea of “being on country” is central to the Aboriginal worldview. The land (or country) is what defines Aboriginal people.

How would you acknowledge and support the culture of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people? ›

Displaying Aboriginal & Torres Strait Islander flags are a significant means of demonstrating our recognition of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people. Flags can be used to promote a sense community, cultural awareness and demonstrate a commitment to acknowledge Aboriginal culture.

What are two issues that Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander people face when engaging with health and community services? ›

Lack of public transport and poor access to telecommunications are both barriers which may hinder access to health services: 61% of Torres Strait Islander adults living in the Torres Strait Indigenous Region had no public transport in their local area (24% in other areas).

What is the difference between aboriginal culture and Torres Strait Islander culture? ›

In brief: Aboriginal Australians are indigenous to mainland Australia and Tasmania who are nomadic. Torres Strait Islanders are minority groups indigenous to Torres Strait Islands who are traders, seafarers and agriculturists.

Why is it important to understand Aboriginal culture? ›

Learning about Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander histories and cultures allows students to develop respect for diversity and understanding of cultural difference. It provides all students with a rich and well-rounded knowledge of Australia's history.

What are 4 key elements of the worldview that many Aboriginal societies have in common? ›

While there is great diversity among Indigenous Peoples, there are also some commonalities in Indigenous worldviews and ways of being. Indigenous worldviews see the whole person (physical, emotional, spiritual, and intellectual) as interconnected to land and in relationship to others (family, communities, nations).

Why it is important to be aware and acknowledge the Indigenous culture in the workplace? ›

Cultural awareness around Aboriginal cultures is important in the workplace because it ensures a fundamental level of respect is maintained throughout all communications. For many workplaces, awareness of Aboriginal culture/s is imperative to operations, such as the family welfare sector.

Why it is important to appreciate Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander knowledges of perspectives about and relationships with the physical landscape? ›

It can foster a strong sense of identity, pride and self-esteem and enables students to develop a wider recognition and understanding of their culture, Country/Place and People.

What are four challenges Aboriginals face today? ›

1) Poorer health
  • Poorer health. ...
  • Lower levels of education. ...
  • Inadequate housing and crowded living conditions. ...
  • Lower income levels. ...
  • Higher rates of unemployment. ...
  • Higher levels of incarceration. ...
  • Higher death rate among children and youth due to unintentional injuries. ...
  • Higher rates of suicide.
26 Apr 2019

What are 4 problems that indigenous people face today? ›

Issues of violence and brutality, continuing assimilation policies, marginalization, dispossession of land, forced removal or relocation, denial of land rights, impacts of large-scale development, abuses by military forces and armed conflict, and a host of other abuses, are a reality for indigenous communities around ...

How do you respect Aboriginal culture? ›

How can I show my respect?
  1. Learn about Aboriginal culture, for example by reading texts written by Aboriginal authors.
  2. Resist the urge to propose solutions for Aboriginal issues, but rather listen deeply. ...
  3. Ask questions during workshops or cultural events you visit.
  4. Avoid stereotypes. ...
  5. Consult, consult, consult.
13 Aug 2020

Where could you obtain local information regarding Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities? ›

National Archives of Australia holds Australian Government records that may include information relevant to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people and their histories.

What resources do aboriginals use? ›

Aboriginal use of resources

They constructed fish traps in creeks and rivers, and speared fish with specially designed spears. They dug yams and other plant roots with digging sticks, collected a wide range of fruits, vegetables, seeds and leaves, and took honey from the native bees.

What are some examples of Indigenous information sources in the country? ›

Stories, dances, songs, and ceremonies are important sources of knowledge in Indigenous cultures. It is important to keep in mind that resources may be non-textual in nature. For example, attending a ceremony or community event could be a learning resource.

Where could you obtain local information in regards to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities? ›

Contact your Local Aboriginal Land Council (LALC), Local Aboriginal Education Consultative Group (AECG) or local council.

What are some of the challenges faced by Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people when accessing services? ›

Lack of public transport and poor access to telecommunications are both barriers which may hinder access to health services: 61% of Torres Strait Islander adults living in the Torres Strait Indigenous Region had no public transport in their local area (24% in other areas).

Why is the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander culture important to Australia? ›

As Australians, we can all be proud to be the home of one of the oldest continuous civilisations on Earth, extending back over 65,000 years. Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people's strong connection to family, land, language, and culture forms the foundation for social, economic, and individual wellbeing.

How could you promote Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander knowledge in your Centre? ›

Attend relevant training. Meet and talk with Aboriginal people outside of the service. Consult with local Lands Council, Aboriginal cultural centres etc. Access resources from organisations such as Indigenous professional Support Unit (IPSU), the Secretariat of National Aboriginal and Islander Child Care (SNAICC) etc.

What are some Aboriginal cultural practices? ›

Most include dance, song, rituals and elaborate body decoration and/or costume. Ancient Aboriginal rock art shows ceremonies and traditions are still continued today.

What benefits do Aboriginals get from the government? ›

See the list of payments and services available to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Australians at Indigenous Australians through Services Australia.
...
Long-term support
  • Parenting Payment.
  • JobSeeker Payment.
  • Carer Allowance.
  • Age Pension.
  • ABSTUDY.
  • Crisis and special help.
  • Family and domestic violence and more…

What are the 4 common sources of information? ›

In this section you will learn about the following types of information sources:
  • Books.
  • Encyclopedias.
  • Magazines.
  • Databases.
  • Newspapers.
  • Library Catalog.
  • Internet.
27 Sept 2021

Why indigenous information is important? ›

From a cultural policy perspective, indigenous media records and preserves traditions, enhances and facilitates cultural forms such as music and crafts, and can also build connections to the wider world.

How do indigenous people communicate and acquire information? ›

Indigenous Peoples have been stewards of communication, passing down knowledge orally through many generations. They are experts of their media. Community radio has been a growing element in Indigenous Peoples exercising their rights and revitalizing their cultures, languages, and traditions.

What is one thing you should take into consideration when referring Aboriginal Torres Strait Islander people to external services? ›

Aboriginal Community Controlled Organisations can provide culturally safe support options for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander children and families and should be a consideration when referring.

Why is it important for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people to have a relationship connection to their Country? ›

The cornerstone of the relationship between Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people and Country is reciprocity. That means mutual respect, maintaining balance, and nurturing the connection, taking only what is needed to ensure the natural resources of the world are never exhausted.

How you can communicate effectively with Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people in your service and the wider community? ›

Use formal addresses when interacting with older people and Elders—or ask them how they wish to be acknowledged. Always wait your turn to speak. It is important to be a good listener and not to talk over anyone. Avoid direct criticisms of specific individuals.

Videos

1. AGECS Reconciliation Series: Seminar 5- Understanding VACCA
(Girraway Ganyi Consultancy)
2. Untangling Privacy, Consent, and Information Security in the Social Service Sector
(Community Door)
3. 210329 4th CoP Meeting
(Women's Health and Equality Queensland)
4. CFCA Webinar – Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander self-determination in child protection
(AIFS resources for the child and family sector)
5. The Internet of Things in Australia: Social Impacts and Issues
(UNSW eLearning)
6. QUT Real World Futures: Connected Cities & People
(TheQUTube)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Twana Towne Ret

Last Updated: 04/22/2023

Views: 6483

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (44 voted)

Reviews: 83% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Twana Towne Ret

Birthday: 1994-03-19

Address: Apt. 990 97439 Corwin Motorway, Port Eliseoburgh, NM 99144-2618

Phone: +5958753152963

Job: National Specialist

Hobby: Kayaking, Photography, Skydiving, Embroidery, Leather crafting, Orienteering, Cooking

Introduction: My name is Twana Towne Ret, I am a famous, talented, joyous, perfect, powerful, inquisitive, lovely person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.